Man Who Robbed Elderly Upper East Siders of Their Watches Learns His Sentence

A surveillance photo released to the public ahead of Sanders’ arrest

The man who pulled watches off the wrists of three older Upper East Siders in the summer of 2024 is going to prison for a long time.

Gary Sanders, 58, has been sentenced to 20 years to life in state prison, the Manhattan DA’s office announced Tuesday. His case went to trial, and all three victims testified against him.

Advertisement

District Attorney Alvin Bragg said Sanders “preyed on three unsuspecting older New Yorkers in brazen, broad daylight attacks.” Prosecutors said he chose the victims because of their age or physical condition, took their valuables by force and injured two of them. Bragg described the victims as longtime Upper East Side residents. He said he hoped the outcome would bring them justice.

The DA’s office laid out how each robbery happened. Each time, Sanders followed the victim and pulled a watch off their left wrist. On August 24, near East 68th Street and Third Avenue, he targeted an 81-year-old man, leaving him with swelling, bruising and pain. An 80-year-old woman was left with swelling and bruising after he robbed her near East 75th Street and Park Avenue on August 31. The first robbery came earlier that month, on August 5, when he went after a 74-year-old woman near East 83rd Street and Park Avenue.

As we previously reported, the stolen watches were a Rolex, an Omega and an Ebel, worth a combined $52,000 according to police reports. Sanders pleaded not guilty when he was arraigned in October 2024.

Police arrested him on September 7, 2024. Prosecutors said that while he was in custody, he gave officers false personal information to keep them from identifying him.

On October 8, a jury convicted Sanders on all counts: two counts of second-degree robbery as a hate crime, one count of third-degree robbery as a hate crime, and one count of false personation.

Have a news tip? Send it to us here!

.




Get us in your inbox!